Slack Vs Hipchat

Channel/Room Sidebar

Slack and HipChat now have similar interfaces, which makes finding rooms and team members easy. They both allow for 1 on 1 conversations with team members, public channels/rooms, and private channels/rooms. Slack lets you see who is online at all times and lets you star members or channels you use most often. HipChat displays team member’s email, phone number, etc. on the top bar when in 1 on 1 conversations.

 

Slack_Channels
HipChat_Channels
Screenshot 2014-12-16 14.10.18
Both of these look similar. HipChat shows user’s contact detail including time zone at the top

 

Integrations

Integrations reduce the need for users to venture across multiple applications and websites to take care of tasks. For example, Slack allows our deposits and invoices to be reported directly into a Sales channel when they are loaded into Freshbooks.

integrations_circular_graphic

At the time of writing Slack offers over 70 integrations, while HipChat supports over 50 integrations (They both update often). Although HipChat offers less integrations at this time, many of them have stronger performance capabilities than Slack’s. Because HipChat is an Atlassian application, it pairs very well with its sibling applications. Apps like Bitbucket, Jira, Stash, Bamboo and Confluence have very strong integrations with HipChat, making HipChat a very useful tool for tech-heavy companies. Our developers miss the ability to easily send repository notifications into the proper project. While this is also possible with Slack, HipChat offers a more seamless integration. Slack also has a bot out of the box that can do some basic things like remind you of when things are due. 

It is also worth noting that both systems allow for custom integrations. Our developers are big fans of Slack’s slash commands and outgoing/incoming Webhooks, for example.

Winner: Tie

 

Emoji

Slack offers more emoji options, but you can create your own for both. (note: you scroll through the HipChat emoji menu). Slack even has a search bar.  HipChat does support more clever emoticons out of the box, yet they are hard to use since i have to go to a separate page to see them.

Slack_Emoji
HipChat_Emoji

 

Pricing

HipChat is significantly cheaper than Slack and offers only two types of subscriptions, making it an attractive and easy choice.
Slack_Pricing

HipChat_Pricing

Other Perks to Consider

These are some of the pro’s that HipChat offers that are not yet available on Slack and vice versa. We summarized the main key differences here:

 

HipChat

  • Voice and video conferencing
  • Screensharing
  • Seamless Atlassian integrations

Slack

  • File comments
  • Seamless switching between two or more Slack accounts
  • Starring (favorites)
  • Theme customization (for brand consistency)

Speaking of theme customization, we created a Christmas theme for the holidays! Copy and paste the following into Slack’s theme customization option to use it!

#2C692E,#AE2828,#AE2828,#FFFFFF,#AE2828,#FFFFFF,#AE2828,#AE2828

 

Slack_App

Conclusion

Both are great apps,  HipChat was first in the field and we really loved it when we used it back in the day, it really helped creating company transparency and personality through emojis. However before Slack showed up they were slow to innovate and their iOS client was pretty buggy (we haven’t used their new version but we are sure it’s much better then before). When Slack came out initially more integration options and better mobile support was enough for us to switch. If you are already using Atlassian products then you will benefit from HipChat greatly. HipChat also has everything a small team might need including Voice and Video conferencing (Slack did purchase Screen Hero screen sharing app recently which is great, but so far it’s not integrated into their client) . We feel that Slack has more soul and is more fun to use, pair that with great support and a team that only focuses on a single product instead of many and you have a clear winner.

What’s your choice? Have you switched from Slack to HipChat? Let us know in the comments!